# Reblog: Mathematical Creativity: Multiple Solutions to the Pencil Sharpener Problem

TheGeometryTeacher has here the four kinds of results gotten from a class given a word problem (about the time needed for a certain event to occur). I like not just the original problem but the different approaches taken to the answer. It seems to me often lost to students, or at least poorly communicated to them, that nearly any interesting problem can be solved several ways over. Probably that’s a reflection of wanting to teach the most efficient way to do any particular problem, so showing more than one approach is judged a waste of time unless the alternate approach is feeding some other class objective.

Given the problem myself, I’d be inclined toward what’s here labelled as the “guessing and checking” approach, as I find a little experimentation like that helps me get to understand the workings of the problem pretty well. If the problem is small enough this might be all that I need to get to the answer. If it’s not, then the experience I get from a couple guesses and seeing why they don’t work would guide me to a more rigorous answer and one that looks more like the graph depicted.

Guessing and checking gets little respect, probably because when you’re trying to train the ability to calculate like “what is eight times seven” it’s hard to distinguish informed guessing from a complete failure to try. (The correct answer is, of course, “nobody knows”; the sevens and eights times tables are beyond human understanding.)

But when you’re venturing into original work for which there may be no guidance what a correct answer is (or whether there is one), or when you’re trying to do something for fun like figure out “What are the odds my roller coaster car will get stuck at the top of a ride like Top Thrill Dragster?” guessing and correcting from that original guess are often effective starting points.

I enjoy watching students exploring a problem that forces them to come up with their own structure for solving it. Today, a group got a chance to mess around with The Pencil Sharpener Problem, which is a problem I posted a month or so ago. (I’ll leave you to read it if you are curious what the problem is.)

From my perspective, what makes this problem interesting for the students is the ease with which it is communicated and the complexity with which is it solved. It seems quite easy. The answer is fairly predictable, but the students quickly found out that if they were going to solve this problem accurately, they were going to need two things:

1. A way to organize their thoughts and,

2. a way to verify their answer.

As long as the solution process included those two things, the students ended up fairly successful…

View original post 359 more words

## Author: Joseph Nebus

I was born 198 years to the day after Johnny Appleseed. The differences between us do not end there. He/him.

## 2 thoughts on “Reblog: Mathematical Creativity: Multiple Solutions to the Pencil Sharpener Problem”

1. Thank you so much for re-blogging my post. This is one of my favorite posts. I’m glad that you were able to find the piece helpful and informing. I am excited to contribute to the global conversation about the art of teaching. I am looking forward to exploring your site. Thanks again.

Like

1. Well, thank you. I’m not teaching at the moment, but I’m trying to keep alert for ways to do better.

Like

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.